Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

Pay for Speedy Review?

Mark Maslin has resigned as an editor for Scientific Reports over a new policy at the journal allowing authors to pay to hasten the peer-review process, ScienceInsider reports. Scientific Reports is one of Nature Publishing Group's open-access journals.

Maslin, a University College London researcher, made his resignation and his reason for it public in a tweet.

"My objections are that it sets up a two-tiered system and instead of the best science being published in a timely fashion it will further shift the balance to well-funded labs and groups," he tells ScienceInsider.

The journal announced last week that this fast-track service, provided by Research Square, would be available to select authors submitting biology manuscript as part of a pilot operation. Authors who pay the $750 to opt into this service are promised a decision on their manuscript within three weeks.

In a blog post, Nature Publishing Group's Nandita Quaderi writes that authors choosing this option would only benefit from a faster decision. "The introduction of this service has no bearing on our editorial decision process — whether we accept, reject, or request revisions," she says.

Malin, though, tells ScienceInsider that "[d]eep consideration and a well thought out review is much more important than its speed. I have had brilliant reviews which have considerably improved my papers and I really appreciated all the time taken."

The Scan

Machine Learning Helps ID Molecular Mechanisms of Pancreatic Islet Beta Cell Subtypes in Type 2 Diabetes

The approach helps overcome limitations of previous studies that had investigated the molecular mechanisms of pancreatic islet beta cells, the authors write in their Nature Genetics paper.

Culture-Based Methods, Shotgun Sequencing Reveal Transmission of Bifidobacterium Strains From Mothers to Infants

In a Nature Communications study, culture-based approaches along with shotgun sequencing give a better picture of the microbial strains transmitted from mothers to infants.

Microbial Communities Can Help Trees Adapt to Changing Climates

Tree seedlings that were inoculated with microbes from dry, warm, or cold sites could better survive drought, heat, and cold stress, according to a study in Science.

A Combination of Genetics and Environment Causes Cleft Lip

In a study published in Nature Communications, researchers investigate what combination of genetic and environmental factors come into play to cause cleft lip/palate.