Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

Not the Best Way to Deal With that Pesky Third Reviewer

Publisher BioMed Central has uncovered several instances of fake peer reviewers, reports Retraction Watch's Ivan Oransky.

A manuscript editor caught most of the cases before the articles were published, but a handful slipped through. The editor noticed spelling errors in the reviewers' names as well as non-institutional email addresses that were changed after the review was in, apparently as part of a cover-up effort.

"We cannot see a clear link between the authors and believe that a third party may be involved, and influencing the peer review process," BMC Central tells Retraction Watch. Oransky says that third party may be a marketing service that helps authors whose papers have been accepted.

To try to stop this from happening again, BMC is no longer allowing authors to recommend reviewers.

"Since this was flagged, we have searched our systems and found several potential false reviewer accounts that seem to have returned peer review reports to several of our journals," the publisher tells Retraction Watch. "At present this amounts to around 50 manuscripts, the majority of which have not been published and are held in our systems."

The manuscripts that have been published will be re-reviewed, Oransky reports, and may be subject to expressions of concern or even retraction.

The Scan

Lung Cancer Response to Checkpoint Inhibitors Reflected in Circulating Tumor DNA

In non-small cell lung cancer patients, researchers find in JCO Precision Oncology that survival benefits after immune checkpoint blockade coincide with a dip in ctDNA levels.

Study Reviews Family, Provider Responses to Rapid Whole-Genome Sequencing Follow-up

Investigators identified in the European Journal of Human Genetics variable follow-up practices after rapid whole-genome sequencing.

BMI-Related Variants Show Age-Related Stability in UK Biobank Participants

Researchers followed body mass index variant stability with genomic structural equation modeling and genome-wide association studies of 40- to 72-year olds in PLOS Genetics.

Genome Sequences Reveal Range Mutations in Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells

Researchers in Nature Genetics detect somatic mutation variation across iPSCs generated from blood or skin fibroblast cell sources, along with selection for BCOR gene mutations.