Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

Rise of the 'Mega-Correction'

So-called "mega-corrections" are starting to creep into the scientific record, say Ivan Oransky and Adam Marcus in Lab Times. Consider a correction published in Nature in September that took three paragraphs to explain what was wrong with one figure, they write. Or a correction published in the Journal of Cell Sciences in December that explained major errors in three different figures and corrected the list of authors as well as the funding source. "We're all for correcting the scientific record, no matter what that takes," Oransky and Marcus write. "We've argued … that scientists should embrace post-publication peer review, of which this would be a sort." However, they question whether mega-corrections are the best way to go about ensuring the accuracy of the scientific record.

The guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics, the authors add, suggest that journals issue a correction rather than a retraction if a small part of an otherwise reliable paper is in error. "So, it ends up depending on what you consider 'a small portion,'" Oransky and Marcus say. "Americans have paid the price for portion size creep, with more and more people becoming obese and diabetic. Journals would do well to avoid the scientific version of that fate."

The Scan

UCLA Team Reports Cost-Effective Liquid Biopsy Approach for Cancer Detection

The researchers report in Nature Communications that their liquid biopsy approach has high specificity in detecting all- and early-stage cancers.

Machine Learning Improves Diagnostic Accuracy of Breast Cancer MRI, Study Shows

Combining machine learning with radiologists' interpretations further increased the diagnostic accuracy of MRIs for breast cancer, a Science Translational Medicine paper finds.

Genome Damage in Neurons Triggers Alzheimer's-Linked Inflammation

Neurons harboring increased DNA double-strand breaks activate microglia to lead to neuroinflammation like that seen in Alzheimer's disease, a new Science Advances study finds.

Long COVID-19 Susceptibility Clues Contained in Blood Plasma Proteome

A longitudinal study in eBioMedicine found weeks-long blood plasma proteome shifts after SARS-CoV-2 infection, along with proteomic signatures that appeared to coincide with long Covid risk.