Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

Reasons for a Retraction

It was because the work couldn't be replicated that David Vaux says he asked to retract a paper he wrote — though the work that could not be reproduced was not originally done by his lab. At Retraction Watch, Vaux recounts that, in the mid-1990s, he reviewed a manuscript from Bellgrau et al. for Nature and was very excited about its findings and their implications, so much so that he wrote a News and Views article about it.

However, as work in his lab tried to build on those findings, Vaux realized that his lab couldn't replicate the original work, and neither could a few others. He writes that he tried to submit a rebuttal to Nature, but it was rejected, as was a submission to Nature Medicine. Eventually that paper was published in PNAS.

"I was becoming increasingly frustrated … when I had a flash of inspiration — I had published a News and Views extolling the virtues of Bellgrau et al.'s paper — now I could retract it!" he writes. And so he did.

But, Vaux adds, correcting the literature should be easier. "Clearly, the processes that allow the scientific record to self-correct can be improved, not least by Nature," he notes.

The Scan

RNA Editing in Octopuses Seems to Help Acclimation to Shifts in Water Temperature

A paper in Cell reports that octopuses use RNA editing to help them adjust to different water temperatures.

Topical Compound to Block EGFR Inhibitors May Ease Skin Toxicities, Study Finds

A topical treatment described in Science Translational Medicine may limit skin toxicities seen with EGFR inhibitor therapy.

Dozen Genetic Loci Linked to Preeclampsia Risk in New GWAS

An analysis of genome-wide association study data in JAMA Cardiology finds genetic loci linked to preeclampsia that have ties to blood pressure.

Cancer Survival Linked to Mutational Burden in Pan-Cancer Analysis

A pan-cancer paper appearing in JCO Precision Oncology suggests tumor mutation patterns provide clues for predicting cancer survival that are independent of other prognostic factors.