Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

But If You Said It in Front of 500 People, Isn't That Sort of Public?

Following up on yesterday's exchange about Cold Spring Harbor changing its meeting policy to make all attendees sign off on privacy guidelines, bloggers are discussing the philosophy behind it: should scientists be able to present data in a talk and expect it to remain private?

DrugMonkey jumps into the fray by noting that the common concern -- being scooped for publication -- isn't assuaged by preventing attendees from broadcasting what they heard at a session. After all, it's likely that "all of the potential scoopers are either in the audience or their friends are," DrugMonkey writes. "The whole idea of publication priority/uniquity is corrosive to science anyway ... a considerable amount of the secrecy sentiment comes from that particular problem in science. So why should we coddle that with academic meeting rules?"

Meanwhile, Anthony Fejes has a post encouraging openness as well. "Unless the conference organizers have explicitly asked each participant to sign a non-disclosure agreement, the conference contents are considered to be a form of public disclosure," he writes. "To strangle the communication between conference attendees and their colleagues ... is to throttle the scientific community itself."

The Scan

Fertility Fraud Found

Consumer genetic testing has uncovered cases of fertility fraud that are leading to lawsuits, according to USA Today.

Ties Between Vigorous Exercise, ALS in Genetically At-Risk People

Regular strenuous exercise could contribute to motor neuron disease development among those already at genetic risk, Sky News reports.

Test Warning

The Guardian writes that the US regulators have warned against using a rapid COVID-19 test that is a key part of mass testing in the UK.

Science Papers Examine Feedback Mechanism Affecting Xist, Continuous Health Monitoring for Precision Medicine

In Science this week: analysis of cis confinement of the X-inactive specific transcript, and more.