Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

How Do You Plead?

An earthquake hit L'Aquila, a town in the Abruzzo region of Italy, in 2009, and more than 300 people died. Soon thereafter, says Popular Science's Juliet Lapidos, the citizens of L'Aquila requested an investigation into a panel of researchers and civil servants that had previously concluded that a major seismic event was unlikely, despite a series of small tremors that had occurred there. Those researchers are now being charged with manslaughter and could get as much as 15 years in prison. "The L'Aquila judge who determined that the case could go to court said the defendants provided 'imprecise, incomplete and contradictory information' and effectively 'thwarted the activities designed to protect the public,'" Lapidos reports.

Many researchers are saying that holding these seismologists criminally responsible for what happened will have a "chilling effect" on science, Lapidos adds. "If months from now, a court finds the scientists guilty, that would be unfair for them and set a dangerous precedent for panelists on future advisory committees, who might feel reluctant to offer any opinion at all," she says. "The ongoing trial should draw researchers' attention to the benefits of declaiming their own uncertainty, and it should remind the rest of us of the chasm between factual evidence and practical advice."

The Scan

Missed Early Cases

A retrospective analysis of blood samples suggests early SARS-CoV-2 infections may have been missed in the US, the New York Times reports.

Limited Journal Editor Diversity

A survey finds low diversity among scientific and medical journal editors, according to The Scientist.

How Much of a Threat?

Science writes that need for a provision aimed at shoring up genomic data security within a new US bill is being questioned.

PNAS Papers on Historic Helicobacter Spread, Brain Development, C. difficile RNAs

In PNAS this week: Helicobacter genetic diversity gives insight into human migrations, gene expression patterns of brain development, and more.