Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

High Impact Papers Appearing More in Non-elite Journals

A team from Google Scholar has found that non-elite journals are publishing an increasing fraction of top-cited articles.

For some 261 subjects, Google's Anurag Acharya and his colleagues examined the 10 most-cited journals and the 1,000 most-cited articles for each year from 1995 to 2012, as they report in a paper posted to arXiv.

In 1995, 149 of the top papers in one representative subject were published in non-elite journals — which the researchers defined as anything other than those 10 most-cited journals — but that number jumped 64 percent to 245 in 2013. The change, they note, was particularly profound for physics and mathematics, which had a 204 percent increase in top-cited papers being published in non-elite journals. The health and medical sciences saw a 98 percent increase.

Further, the researchers add that the overall percentage of citations to articles in non-elite journals increased from 27 percent in 1995 to 47 percent in 2013.

Acharya and his colleagues suggest that now that it's as easy to access articles in non-elite journals as elite journals, "researchers are increasingly building on and citing work published everywhere."

Hadas Shema, a library scientist at Bar-Ilan University in Israel tells ScienceInsider that "[t]heir explanation for the results is definitely sound." However, she points out the large jump in non-elite journal citations for physics and math could be due in part to the creation of the arXiv repository.

The Scan

Steps for Quick Review

The US Food and Drug Administration is preparing for the quick review of drugs and vaccines for the Omicron variant, according to the Wall Street Journal.

Moving Away From Using Term 'Race'

A new analysis finds that geneticists are using the term "race" in their papers less than in years past, as Science reports.

Point of the Program

The Guardian writes that some scientists have called the design of a UK newborn sequencing program into question.

Science Papers Present Multi-Omic Analysis of Lung Cells, Regulation of Cardiomyocyte Proliferation

In Science this week: a multi-omic analysis of lung cells focuses on RIT1-regulated pathways, and more.