Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

A Double-Edged Sword

Over at her blog, Katie PhD says publication requirements for graduate students can be beneficial:

Not only do you prepare your work in the most polished way possible and deal with the peer review system first hand, you make your transition up the academic ladder far more straightforward. In some fields it is impossible to get a postdoctoral position without a good publication record, and forget trying to get a faculty position without them. By requiring at least one first author paper, then, a graduate program is helping its students.

Of course, once they've submitted their work, grad students have little control over the pace of publication. "A prospective PhD student could end up mired in this mess for a really long time through no fault of their own," she says of the peer review process, among other pre-publication procedures. For that and other reasons, Katie PhD says publication requirements can be detrimental:

The PhD experience is about so much more than publishing a paper (or two, or three), and while navigating peer-review successfully is an important part of a grad student’s training, all the other aspects of this training should not be overlooked. … We are here to learn to become independent researchers and educators, not slaves to the peer-review process.
The Scan

UCLA Team Reports Cost-Effective Liquid Biopsy Approach for Cancer Detection

The researchers report in Nature Communications that their liquid biopsy approach has high specificity in detecting all- and early-stage cancers.

Machine Learning Improves Diagnostic Accuracy of Breast Cancer MRI, Study Shows

Combining machine learning with radiologists' interpretations further increased the diagnostic accuracy of MRIs for breast cancer, a Science Translational Medicine paper finds.

Genome Damage in Neurons Triggers Alzheimer's-Linked Inflammation

Neurons harboring increased DNA double-strand breaks activate microglia to lead to neuroinflammation like that seen in Alzheimer's disease, a new Science Advances study finds.

Long COVID-19 Susceptibility Clues Contained in Blood Plasma Proteome

A longitudinal study in eBioMedicine found weeks-long blood plasma proteome shifts after SARS-CoV-2 infection, along with proteomic signatures that appeared to coincide with long Covid risk.