Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

Back and Forth on Failure Rates

Stanford University's Stephen Quake and his colleagues published a paper last month in Nature Methods in which they reported that RNA sequencing could accurately and quantitatively measure the transcriptome of single cells.

The University of California, Berkeley's Lior Pachter wrote at his blog, Bits of DNA, that the paper had a few issues. For instance, Pachter says that the experiment, like other RNA-seq studies, had a high failure rate. "The problem with the paper is that instead of reporting the failures and discarding them before analysis, they instead use all of the data when performing comparisons between single-cell and bulk RNA-Seq," Pachter writes. He adds that the authors may have then spun their results a bit too favorably.

Quake now responds at Methagora, the Nature Methods blog, that the experiments described in the paper had a 3 percent failure rate. "We conservatively included ALL of the single cell data in our analyses and thus if one follows Pachter’s prescription to only analyze the experiments that he deems 'successful,' then the results will be even better than we reported," Quake says.

The Scan

Machine Learning Helps ID Molecular Mechanisms of Pancreatic Islet Beta Cell Subtypes in Type 2 Diabetes

The approach helps overcome limitations of previous studies that had investigated the molecular mechanisms of pancreatic islet beta cells, the authors write in their Nature Genetics paper.

Culture-Based Methods, Shotgun Sequencing Reveal Transmission of Bifidobacterium Strains From Mothers to Infants

In a Nature Communications study, culture-based approaches along with shotgun sequencing give a better picture of the microbial strains transmitted from mothers to infants.

Microbial Communities Can Help Trees Adapt to Changing Climates

Tree seedlings that were inoculated with microbes from dry, warm, or cold sites could better survive drought, heat, and cold stress, according to a study in Science.

A Combination of Genetics and Environment Causes Cleft Lip

In a study published in Nature Communications, researchers investigate what combination of genetic and environmental factors come into play to cause cleft lip/palate.