Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

Not Yet Perfected


In a profile of Johns Hopkins University's Bert Vogelstein in Science, Jocelyn Kaiser says he and his co-PI Kenneth Kinzler have helped "lay the foundation of cancer genetics," work that now inspires other researchers to use genetics to predict cancer risk and develop personalized treatments. And yet, Kaiser adds, Vogelstein and Kinzler seem to spend most of their time these days being skeptical about these efforts. "Vogelstein seems to enjoy pricking balloons. Recently, he has focused on a new target: exuberance over targeted cancer drugs," Kaiser says.

Vogelstein says his focus on targeted drugs began when he read a paper on a patient with melanoma who developed resistance to BRAF inhibitors only five months after the treatment wiped out all his tumors. To investigate resistance, Kaiser says, researchers in the Vogelstein-Kinzler lab are using a "liquid biopsy" technique, where they draw blood samples from patients and then analyze the sample to find tumor DNA. "With Harvard University computational biologist Martin Nowak, they devised a model showing that even before the patient begins treatment, some tumor cells always carry genes with random mutations that can support resistance to targeted drugs," Kaiser says. This form of resistance, they wrote last month in Nature, is therefore 'a fait accompli.'"

At In the Pipeline, Derek Lowe says there are many labs using the liquid biopsy idea, but as with any screening method, the worry here is the rate of false positives. "As you make finer and finer distinctions among different tumor types, the incidence of any given one in the population gets lower and lower, and thus your test has to be more and more reliable in order to avoid overdiagnosing hordes of panicked patients," he says. If liquid biopsy works as a testing method, it would be a great advance for patients, he adds. But a less-than-perfect test would be worse than not having one at all.

The Scan

Two J&J Doses

Johnson & Johnson says two doses of its SARS-CoV-2 vaccine provides increased protection against symptomatic COVID-19, CNN reports.

Pfizer-BioNTech Vaccine Response in Kids

The Pfizer-BioNTech SARS-CoV-2 vaccine in a lower-dose format appears to generate an immune response among children, according to the Washington Post.

Chicken Changes to Prevent Disease

The Guardian writes that researchers are looking at gene editing chickens to help prevent future pandemics.

PNAS Papers on Siberian Dog Ancestry, Insect Reproduction, Hippocampal Neurogenesis

In PNAS this week: ancestry and admixture among Siberian dogs, hormone role in fruit fly reproduction, and more.