Skip to main content
Premium Trial:

Request an Annual Quote

Invitrogen Wins US Appeals Case in IP-Infringement Suit Against Stratagene

Click here for an updated version of this article.

NEW YORK, Oct. 13 (GenomeWeb News) - Invitrogen today said that a USappeals court ruled in its favor in a 4-year-old patent-infringement suit against Stratagene.

The appeal overturned a 2002 decision by a federal district court in Texasand ruled that Stratagene infringes a patent involving a process for developing competent cell products.

Specifically, the US District Court for the Western District of Texas, the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit found that "substantially all" of the chemically competent cell products sold by Stratagene infringe Invitrogen's patent.

 

The Court of Appeals remanded the case to the district court for further proceedings, Invitrogen said in a statement today.

"We plan to vigorously pursue all available remedies for Stratagene's infringement of our intellectual property as this case proceeds in the District Court," John Cottingham, senior vice president and general counsel for Invitrogen, said in a statement today.  

 

Officials for Stratagene were not immediately available for comment.

 

Invitrogen sued Stratagene in March 2001 for allegedly infringing a patent that covers a process to treat E. Coli cells to cause them to be more effective at absorbing foreign DNA, thereby becoming "competent."

 

Invitrogen claims it sells more than 30 different competent cell products and the act of buying any of them provides an Invitrogen customer a "limited license" under the patent, No. 4,981,797, to use them for research purposes. From the outset, Invitrogen has claimed that Stratagene's competent cell products and their customers' use of them are not licensed under the '797 patent.

Five months later, in August, Invitrogen voluntarily withdrew its allegations, made against Stratagene's electrocompetent cell and certain chemically competent cell products, Stratagene said.

 

Invitrogen's position further eroded that month when the District Court narrowed its interpretation of the '797 patent, Stratagene said at the time. Following the recent decision, Invitrogen withdrew its remaining patent-infringement allegations.

 

"We still feel strongly that our patent holds ... and we decided to continue to fight in appeals court," Mary Cassoni, an Invitrogen spokesperson, said at the time.

 

"This particular lawsuit doesn't have a lot of risk for us," said Cassoni. "If we lost, we wouldn't be collecting royalties from Stratagene that we believe we're due. This still doesn't affect our business."

 

In January 2002, the US District Court for the Western District of Texas said Stratagene does not infringe the '797 patent.

The Scan

Unique Germline Variants Found Among Black Prostate Cancer Patients

Through an exome sequencing study appearing in JCO Precision Oncology, researchers have found unique pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants within a cohort of Black prostate cancer patients.

Analysis of Endogenous Parvoviral Elements Found Within Animal Genomes

Researchers at PLOS Biology have examined the coevolution of endogenous parvoviral elements and animal genomes to gain insight into using the viruses as gene therapy vectors.

Saliva Testing Can Reveal Mosaic CNVs Important in Intellectual Disability

An Australian team has compared the yield of chromosomal microarray testing of both blood and saliva samples for syndromic intellectual disability in the European Journal of Human Genetics.

Octopus Brain Complexity Linked to MicroRNA Expansions

Investigators saw microRNA gene expansions coinciding with complex brains when they analyzed certain cephalopod transcriptomes, as they report in Science Advances.