Eugenie Scott to Leave NCSE

Eugenie Scott, the founding CEO of the National Center for Science Education, will be leaving that post at the end of the year, ScienceInsider reports. NCSE defends the teaching of evolution and climate change in science classrooms in the US.

Scott founded NCSE in 1987 to combat efforts to introduce creationism into local schools near the University of Kentucky, where she was a faculty member. With 15 people now part of NCSE, ScienceInsider notes that the organization has become a more than $1 million a year operation that supplies resources and advice to teachers and keeps an eye on legislation.

"We've learned from Day 1 that you don't blunt those attacks by simply shoveling science onto the debate," Scott says. "You need to recognize the political and economic and cultural issues in play. In the end, it comes down to your powers of persuasion."

The search for Scott's successor is underway, NCSE adds.

This Week in PNAS

A University of California-led team sequenced the genomes of dozens of Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis isolates in an effort to understand the evolutionary history of the fungus — an amphibian pathogen that's had particularly detrimental effects on amphibian populations in the Americas. As they report in the early, online edition of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, the researchers found a great deal of genetic diversity amongst 29 B. dendrobatidis isolates collected from sites around the world, consistent with a complex evolutionary history for the fungus. They also saw signs of selective pressure on genes coding for protease enzymes, suggesting these processes are prone to shifts during evolutionary transitions.

Mutations to the RASA1 gene can cause conditions involving abnormalities to the lymphatic fluid-carrying vasculature, according to a study by researchers from Texas and Michigan. The group unearthed frame-shift mutations in RASA1 when they did whole-exome sequencing on a 20-year-old individual with a lymphatic condition called Parkes-Weber syndrome and his unaffected parents. Together with analyses of the affected individual's vasculature, the findings suggest RASA1 mutations may lead to unusual lymphatic vascular architecture, study authors say — a notion supported by experiments in mice missing the RASA1 gene. Even so, RASA1 mutations seem to have variable expressivity since the unaffected father in the exome-sequenced trio carried the same RASA1 alteration found in his Parkes-Weber syndrome-affected son.

For another study slated to appear online this week in PNAS, Cornell University researchers relied on data from the Drosophila Genetic Reference Panel to tally up natural genetic variation in the fruit fly — information that they used to help find new players in endoplasmic reticulum stress response pathways. The team treated flies from 114 sequenced DGRP lines with an ER stress-inducing compound called tunicamycin. By following flies' survival times and looking at how they corresponded with both array-based gene expression profiles and SNP patterns, the investigators identified 25 candidate ER stress response genes. Their follow-up functional experiments suggested that at least 17 of the genes could be plausible ER stress response pathway participants.

Emil Frei Dies

Emil Frei, an oncologist who worked at the National Cancer Institute, the MD Anderson Cancer Center, and the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, has died, the New York Times reports. He was 89. The Times notes that, in the mid-1950s, Frei was among the first to promote the use of combination chemotherapy.

Frei, his colleague Emil Freireich at NCI, and others studied the use of multiple chemotherapy agents to treat pediatric leukemia. They found that, in combination, they could use less of each drug, limiting the toxic effects of the drugs on patients, but better attacking the cancer. Among the patients Frei treated was Edward M. Kennedy, Jr., who had osteosarcoma.

Further, the Times notes that in his book, The Emperor of All Maladies, physician and author Siddhartha Mukherjee called Frei a "charming" physician. "To watch him manage critically ill children and their testy, nervous parents was to watch a champion swimmer glide through water — so adept in the art that he made artistry vanish," Mukherjee wrote.

To Be Clearer

The American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics, which recently issued guidelines regarding the return of incidental findings, has published a clarification regarding that statement.

The guidelines, released during the ACMG annual meeting in Phoenix in March, recommended that certain genetic findings uncovered by a lab during whole-exome or whole-genome sequencing of a patient be reported back to the physician and patient, even if those findings were unrelated to why the patient was undergoing testing. For example, if the patient is being tested for mutations linked to heart disease, but sequencing turns up a mutation in, say BRCA1 that predisposes that patient to cancer, that finding should be reported.

After the statement was released, some critics said the report was "too conservative" while others said it overlooked patient autonomy, among other issues.

In its clarification, the ACMG reiterates its thoughts on patient autonomy, reporting findings from children, laboratory policies, communicating results, and predicting disease likelihood.

For example, in addressing patient autonomy, the group says its reason for advising returning results was because its list of mutations and conditions only included pathogenic variants that had a high likelihood of leading to disease. "The rationale for our recommendations was that not reporting a laboratory test result that conveys a near certainty of an adverse yet potentially preventable medical outcome would be unethical," it adds.

In a blog post at the Huffington Post, guideline author Robert Green adds that "autonomy is not removed, but shifted to a more appropriate place" under these guidelines. "[O]rdering physicians should receive a report that includes the potentially dangerous incidental mutation, and thus informed, the physician and patient together can choose to learn more about the illness that it implicates. … Absent the knowledge that such a mutation exists, patients will not have any authentic opportunity to inform themselves or exert any choice over this danger," he adds.

New Councilors

The US National Institutes of Health has appointed 10 new members to its Council of Councils, which advises the NIH director on the activities of the Division of Program Coordination, Planning, and Strategic Initiatives.

The division looks to identify scientific opportunities, public health challenges, and knowledge gaps. The advisory council has 27 members, and the 10 new ones include Stanford University School of Medicine's Carlos Bustamante, Janice Clements at John Hopkins University School of Medicine, and Nancy Haigwood from Oregon Health and Science University.

This Week in PLOS

Relaxation practices such as yoga, meditation, and repetitive prayer are associated with shifts in the expression of metabolic, immune, and stress response pathways genes, according to a study in PLOS One. A Massachusetts-led team did array-based gene expression analyses on blood samples from 26 healthy individuals over eight weeks, as each embarked on a relaxation response program. This gene expression data, coupled with a systems biology network analysis, suggest that both short and longer term relaxation practices can produce a dip in the stress response and inflammation-related gene expression, along with a boost in the expression of certain metabolic, insulin, and mitochondrial genes.

Researchers from Brazil and France looked at the relationship between a Chagas disease-causing parasite and its insect host for another PLOS One study. The team developed complementary DNA libraries with RNA from the guts of Triatoma infestans insects that did or did not carry the Chagas disease parasite, Trypanosoma cruzi. The resulting expressed sequence tag data revealed genes with an uptick or decline in expression in the infected insects. The study's authors also saw metabolic- and immune-related transcripts with similar expression profiles under both conditions. "[T]his work provides the first global analysis of expression profiles from the midgut of a Chagas disease vector under T. cruzi infection," they write, "with a resulting repertoire of transcripts that are important in the elucidation of metabolic processes in T. infestans."

In PLOS Genetics, researchers from Canada and the US describe the approach they used to look at the interplay between nucleosome architecture and transcriptional regulation. The team tracked nucleosome position patterns in dozens of yeast strains carrying loss-of-function deletions or conditional mutations to genes influencing histone, chromatin, or transcription-related processes. Together with information on yeast strains treated with compounds known to alter some of the same pathways, findings from the experiment "confirm and extend the roles of chromatin remodelers and chaperones as major determinants of genic nucleosome positioning," the researchers write, "and these data provide a valuable resource for future studies."

Hard Choices

Earlier non-invasive prenatal testing can lead to difficult decisions for prospective parents, USA Today writes. "Rapid technological advances are opening up a new era, doctors say — one in which couples have an unprecedented glimpse of the forming child, and with this new information an often-wrenching choice: proceed with the pregnancy or terminate it," it adds.

Because they are not invasive, early screens will likely appeal to more women, the paper adds, noting that only about 2 percent of women opt for invasive testing, though such tests may be used to confirm NIPT results. Newer cell-free DNA screens, like the one from Sequenom, among other companies, can be conducted as early as nine weeks. Early results allow women with negative results to bypass invasive screening and enable women with positive results to, if they choose, undergo an earlier termination, which carries fewer risks, USA Today says.

While advances in technology are giving prospective parents more information, and earlier, the choice they face remains the same. "This technology has not given us some way to magically prevent the condition or cure the baby," Ruth Faden, director of the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics, says. "The pregnancy will be terminated or the baby will be born with it."

And that decision is intensely personal. Melanie Perkins McLaughlin, who received a Down syndrome diagnosis 20 weeks into her pregnancy, continued her pregnancy and now talks to other prospective parents with that diagnosis. "I would never in a million years judge them," McLaughlin tells USA Today. "Who is anybody else to judge somebody in that situation? Even if you've been in that position, with a prenatal diagnosis, everyone is an individual and every situation is different."

Poli-Sci and the Rest Will Follow

New efforts in by Republicans in Congress to require that the National Science Foundation ensure that the studies it funds meet certain criteria that lawmakers would judge have stirred up questions about whether any science may be safe from grant-level oversight by lawmakers.

LiveScience contributor Wynne Parry writes that the efforts by Representative Lamar Smith (R-Texas) and Senator Tom Coburn (R-Okla.) have created "a battle over science" by trying to make NSF justify to Congress the value to society of the research projects that it funds.

Writing in Science today, Columbia University Professor Kenneth Prewitt says that Coburn's recent success in forcing NSF to certify that any political science projects it funds are promoting the national security and economic interests of the US could open the door to even broader efforts to meddle in the scientific enterprise.

"Every scientific discipline has a stake in undoing the damage inflicted on political science, and, in fact, to the national interest, by the Coburn criteria," Prewitt says, adding that scientists "should vigorously contest any effort to apply those criteria more broadly."

This week, Smith proposed legislation that would expand on Coburn's political science clause and require that NSF certify that all of its research advances "the national health, prosperity, and welfare" of the US.

Prewitt says there are there are three major problems with these sorts of rules, which enable lawmakers to "micromanage" science funding.

Rules like these favor research with near-term benefits, but overlook the long-term potential of lines of inquiry that may pay off in unknown ways. He says that Congress has a history of supporting both present and future-oriented research, the likes of which led to the development of the Internet.

"Today, we cannot know how and when the science of the Higgs boson subatomic particle will prove useful. But conditions will change; the knowledge will be used," Prewitt writes.

Criteria like that in Coburn's amendment also "weaken the way science builds theories," and miss the larger point that "science is an interconnected enterprise."

Lastly, the peer review process will be hurt by such rules, Prewitt argues, because "Congressional intimidation" will lead scientists to pursue the kinds of projects that lawmakers want, and avoiding those that some do not want, such as research that hits political hot-buttons, like studies involving climate change, stem cells, and evolution.

This Week in Science

In Science this week, a group of Chinese researchers report on the use of reverse genetics to gain insights into how H5N1 avian flu can spread to, and between, mammals. In the past, avian flu viruses have crossed species barriers by reassorting with mammal-infective viruses in intermediate livestock hosts. The team created 127 reassortant viruses between a duck isolate of H5N1 and a highly transmissible human H1N1 virus. They tested the viruses' virulence in mice and transmissibility to guinea pigs, which both have avian and mammalian types of airway receptors, and found that some reassortments were transmissible by airborne droplet, although they were not lethal. The findings indicate that avian H5N1 subtype viruses have the "potential to acquire mammalian transmissibility by reassortment," the researchers write.

Also in Science, researchers from the University of Oxford publish data giving clues about how one type of long, non-coding RNA, or lncRNA, is regulated. The investigators found that an lncRNA they had identified in Arabidopsis is regulated through its interaction with an R-loop, a triple-stranded nucleic acid structure formed by an RNA/DNA hybrid and a displaced single-stranded DNA. Based on the findings, the team concludes that differential stabilization of R-loops could be a "general mechanism influencing gene expression in many organisms."

There You Are

Harvard University researchers were able to correctly identify between 84 percent and 97 percent of Personal Genome Project participants through demographic information they provided.

The Personal Genome Project, led by George Church at Harvard Medical School, began about a half dozen years ago to examine the interactions among genotype, the environment, and phenotype. Project participants provide genomic information as well as health information and some other personal data. The project notes that privacy cannot be guaranteed, though the online profiles do not include names or addresses.

Latanya Sweeney and her colleagues write in a paper, available at the arXiv preprint server, that they matched demographic data— such as ZIP code, age, and gender — from 579 of 1,130 public PGP profiles to data housed in voter or other public records. From this, they received 241 unique matches.

The researchers shared their findings with the PGP to determine the accuracy of their matches. According to the response from the PGP, 84 percent of Sweeney and her team's matches were correct, and, the researchers note, if nicknames were taken into consideration, that proportion of correct matches increases to 97 percent. "Our ability to learn their names is based on their demographics, not their DNA, thereby revisiting an old vulnerability that could be easily thwarted with minimal loss of research value," they write.

Sweeney and her colleagues add that by making age and location data a bit fuzzier, PGP participants would be able to protect themselves from identification. They note that they developed a tool to help PGP participants make such changes.

"That should make the Personal Genome Project significantly more private for those who choose this option. It should also serve as a warning for future projects involving personal data that privacy isn't always as easy to protect as it might at first seem," the Physics arXiv blog adds.

Curiosity and the Cat…

A Florida teen was expelled and charged with a felony after a science project she was working on led to what Riptide, a news blog at the Miami New Times, describes as a "tiny pop and a small amount of smoke." No one was injured and there was no damage.

Kiera Wilmot, a 16-year-old student at Bartow High School, was known to have a good record, and the principal there, Ron Pritchard, said Wilmot "is a good kid," according to Tampa Bay's News 10.

"She made a bad choice," Pritchard said, adding that "she wanted to see what would happen [when the chemicals mixed] and was shocked by what it did." Riptide adds that she mixed toilet bowl cleaner and aluminum foil in a plastic water bottle.

Wilmot is to be tried as an adult on charges of possessing/discharging a weapon on school grounds and discharging a destructive device. The school district adds that she was expelled as students need to know "there are consequences to their actions," according to Riptide

At Southern Fried Science, Andrew David Thaler wonders if responses like that will stifle scientific curiosity. "Many young scientists have a brush with danger due to a combination of curiosity and experimentation," he writes. "High school programs should be nurturing that curiosity and fostering responsible experimentation, not punishing it."

Thaler also asked Twitter followers, many of whom he says are current scientists, whether they had had any such lab mishaps in high school. He has a Storify of their responses. For example, @rasliche tweeted: "Launched rocket in hs that tipped after igniting, shot at class, hit building window. No damage, but def not safe. Got A+."

While Daily Scan never caused the sprinklers to go off, there was a harrowing incident with some ethidium bromide.

Yo Momma's Genome

File this under "sentences we never thought we'd type:" If you haven't checked out the "YoMammasGenomeSoFat" hashtag on Twitter, you should really stop whatever you're doing right now and take a look.

Yes, the life sciences community is trying its collective hand at "Yo Momma" jokes, and, what do you know, it turns out applying genomics geekery to insult comedy is a lot of fun.

For instance, from @pdoofus: "#YoMammasGenomeSoFat her introns don't get spliced…they get bariatric surgery."

And then you have your more inside baseball jokers like @evolvability, who mixes in a little sequencing platform humor: "#YoMammasGenomeSoFat it makes PacBio look like short read technology" and @Graham_Coop, who can't resist taking a swipe at the scientific press's coverage of the ENCODE project: "#YoMammasGenomeSoFat even encode press coverage thinks it can't all be functional ;-)"

Good times.

This Week in Nature

Based on genomic, transcriptomic, and proteomic analyses of nearly 400 tumors, the Cancer Genome Atlas Research Network team uncovered four subtypes of endometrial cancer, as it reports in Nature this week. These four categories subdivide the tumors based on their mutation frequency: POLE ultramutated, microsatellite instability hypermutated, copy-number low, and copy-number high tumors. "This integrated analysis provides key molecular insights into tumour classification, which may have a direct effect on treatment recommendations for patients, and provides opportunities for genome-guided clinical trials and drug development," the researchers write.

Daily Scan sister publication GenomeWeb Daily News has more on this study here.

Also in Nature, researchers led by Roland Beckmann from the Ludwig-Maximilians University in Germany present the structures of both the human and fruit fly 80S ribosomes in complex with translation factor eEF2, E-site transfer RNA, and Stm1-like proteins. Using high-resolution cryo-electron-microscopy density maps, predicted secondary structures for rRNA expansion segments, and the yeast and Tetrahymena 80S crystal structures, the researchers built molecular models of the Homo sapiens and Drosophila melanogaster subunits. "These structures not only illustrate the co-evolution of metazoan-specific ribosomal RNA with ribosomal proteins but also reveal the presence of two additional structural layers in metazoan ribosomes, a well-ordered inner layer covered by a flexible RNA outer layer," the authors note.

Over in Nature Genetics, BGI researchers and their colleagues report on the draft genomes of two turtles, the soft-shell turtle and the green sea turtle. Their results point to a split from the bird-crocodilian lineage about 267.9 million years ago to 248.3 million years ago. In addition, they uncover evidence of expansions in olfactory receptor genes in these two turtles, which may be due to a gene duplication event. All in all their "results suggest that turtle evolution was accompanied by an unexpectedly conservative vertebrate phylotypic period, followed by turtle-specific repatterning of development to yield the novel structure of the shell," the researchers write.

GWDN also covers this article here.