Lobby Rules

The chair of the US House of Representatives appropriations subcommittee Jack Kingston (R-Ga.) says that some grants funded by the National Institutes of Health violate the prohibition against lobbying, ScienceInsider reports. In a letter to NIH Director Francis Collins, Kingston points out what he terms "questionable grants," including one that he says may sponsor an advocacy group. He says such grants need to be investigated.

That particular grant, ScienceInsider adds, is a one-year grant to George Mason University's Catherine Gallagher, a criminologist who is studying medical issues facing young prison inmates. Her grant abstract says her work "is intended to engage the medical, public health, criminal justice, policy, legal and advocacy communities by uniting diverse disciplines around a common issue." And Kingston says that such research as well as other examples he gives are not core to the NIH mission.

Kingston's questions aren't limited to NIH. ScienceInsider notes that he has also asked the Department of Health and Human Services Inspector General to look into research by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to reduce obesity and smoking rates for violations of lobbying rules.

This Week in Science

In this week's Science, four articles discuss the genomics of cancer. A team from the Johns Hopkins Kimmel Cancer Center suggests that grouping cancer-associated genes by their function can help simplify the complexity of data from genome studies, while a University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill researcher discusses ways to use whole-genome sequencing data diagnostically and in the development of personalized therapies. A Harvard Medical School team presents an overview of epigenetic regulation of cellular fates and the shared mechanisms of differentiation of healthy and cancerous cells. Finally, a University of Helsinki duo "call[s] for the international development of standards to facilitate the clinical use of germline information arising from diagnostic cancer genome sequencing."

Also in Science, researchers from Stanford University report on the development of a new genetic circuit based on changing the structure of DNA. The team created a three-terminal device architecture that uses bacteriophage serine integrases to "control the flow of RNA polymerase along DNA. Integrase-mediated inversion or deletion of DNA-encoding transcription terminators or a promoter modulate transcription rates," as they write in their paper. The researchers say that the work enables the engineering of amplifying logic gates to control transcription rates within and across various organisms.

IOM Looks at the Economics of Genomic Medicine

The Institute of Medicine has released the summary of a workshop it hosted last July to discuss the economic issues likely to arise in the age of genomic medicine.

The workshop brought together economists, regulators, payors, researchers, patients, and other stakeholders to discuss various economic factors likely to influence the integration of genomic data into healthcare.

IOM notes in the report that the workshop was one of a series that it hosted on genomic medicine, "but it was the first focused specifically on economic issues."

The 109-page report outlines "major themes" of the workshop, based on a presentation by Gregory Feero, who was special advisor to the director of the National Human Genome Research Institute at the time.

Specific economic issues can vary by application and by setting, according to Feero's summary. Therefore, "improved methods are needed for assessing value, personal utility, and patient preferences," the report states.

In addition, public health, clinical care, and academic medicine "have different economic assessment models," which "have to be aligned in a way that makes a difference to patients," the report notes.

Other considerations include the need for better and quicker approaches to perform economic evaluations of genetic and genomic tests since evaluating tests and variants one by one "will be too daunting."

Feero also recommended that economic analyses be integrated into all ongoing whole-genome sequencing clinical studies, and noted that "the economic incentives for test and evidence development under the current system of reimbursement versus a value-based pricing approach that incorporates the intellectual cost of interpretation need to be further explored."

Elementary, My Dear

Eagle Genomics has released a new version of its Elements of Bioinformatics table, a periodic table-like representation of all the currently available software for bioinformaticians as well as the years they became available.

Much like the chemical periodic table, each tool has a two-letter acronym. Each tool type — aligner, assembler, genome browser, and so on — is assigned a color and tools that fall into that category are grouped together. Clicking on the acronyms opens up a brief description of the software along with information about how to download it and what operating systems to use.

Other features of the table include a slider that allows you to go back to 1970 and see what tools were available back then, and compare the progress that has been made in bioinformatics through the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s, 2000s and right up to the present day.

Finally, the table also distinguishes between open source software, tools that are free for academics, and those that are sold commercially.

Oklahoma Considers DNA Testing for Convicted Criminals

Oklahoma's Senate Judiciary Committee has approved a measure that would allow convicted criminals to request DNA testing of evidence, the Associated Press reports.

The committee passed the proposal called the Postconviction DNA Act 8-0 this week. Sponsored by Republican state Sen. Jim Halligan of Stillwater, the bill would create a process by which convicted criminals can have DNA testing performed on evidence in their cases. According to the AP, if the bill passes, Oklahoma would be the last state in the US to implement such a program.

The measure requires passage by the entire Oklahoma Senate before the state's House of Representatives takes it up for consideration.

The state's chief public defender tells AP that DNA testing done after conviction has exonerated more than 300 people nationally "in the last few decades," including almost one dozen in Oklahoma.

Cancer Meets SEO

The same tools you use for looking up cat videos might also offer scientists new insights into cancer, Jason Bittel writes this week in Slate.

Highlighting a recent paper in the journal Cancer Research, Bittel describes how researchers at the University of Southern California are using an algorithm "similar to Google PageRank" to better understand patterns of lung cancer metastases.

Using data from old lung cancer autopsy reports, the researchers are using Markov chains to work backwards from this data to develop models of how metastatic lung cancer spreads.

As USC researcher Paul Newton tells Bittel: "Basically we're doing the inverse of what Google does. They know the transition probabilities and compute the steady-state, we know the steady-state and compute the transition probabilities."

Using this Markov chain-based analysis, the team has identified regions of the body – such as the liver, lymph nodes, and bones – that appear to trap and halt the spread of metastases, and regions – such as the kidneys and adrenal glands – that appear to promote their proliferation. Bittel notes that these findings could offer "a new way to target treatments and lessen or prevent the spread of cancer."

Basement Biology

A brown-haired teenager curious about why his brother had red hair built his own PCR instrument to find out, eventually winning the UK Young Engineer of the Year award.

As reported in the Halifax Courier, 18-year old Fred Turner won the award for his project called "Genetics at Home: Building a PCR Machine and Other Equipment for Setting up a Home Genetics Lab," after wowing the judges at the 2013 National Science and Engineering Competition with his home-made PCR machine.

Turner built the instrument from the ground up in his basement for a fraction of what it would cost to buy one from an instrument vendor, and now plans to carry out experiments investigating the genetic mutations behind his red-headed brother and mother. Turner says he plans to let other people use his kit to build their own PCR instruments.

This Week in Nature

In Nature this week, a multinational team reported the draft genome of the wheat A-genome progenitor Triticum urartu, or bread wheat, one of the most widely consumed food crops in the world. They identified protein-coding gene models, performed genome structure analyses, and assessed the potential for the draft sequence’s use in studying agronomically important genes and molecular marker development.

Also in Nature, researchers, including those involved in the bread wheat study, published a draft genome of the wild diploid grass Aegilops tauschii, which hybridized with the cultivated tetraploid wheat Triticum turgidum thousands of years ago to give rise to hexaploid wheat. Whole-genome analysis uncovered gene family expansion in Ae. tauschii of “agronomically relevant gene families that were associated with disease resistance, abiotic stress tolerance, and grain quality.” The findings give insights into the environmental adaptation of bread wheat and can help in “defining large and complicated genomes of wheat species.”

'Is Siri a Doctor?'

Eric Topol took some ribbing last night as he visited the Colbert Report to promote his book, The Creative Destruction of Medicine.

Topol, a cardiologist and director of the Scripps Translational Science Institute, is a proponent of the use of smartphones and other mobile technologies for medical use, and recently saved the lives of two patients using such methods.

On the show, he used a number of smartphone-enabled medical devices to perform a cardiogram and an ear canal exam on host Stephen Colbert, who asked, "are you Dick Tracy?”

Topol said that smartphones can be useful for remote monitoring, but it's clear that these devices won't replace trained doctors any time soon.

"Siri, am I dying?" Colbert asked his phone.

"I really can't say," she replied.

Beyond the PSA Test

The New York Times highlights a number of omics tests that are on the horizon to supplement the PSA test that is currently the standard of care for prostate cancer screening.

As the Times notes, the PSA test picks up a large number of cancers that are harmless, so many men with positive test results end up undergoing unnecessary surgery or radiation treatment. Indeed, the US Preventive Services Task Force has recommended against PSA-based screening for prostate cancer because "many men are harmed as a result of prostate cancer screening and few, if any, benefit."

The Times reports that more than a dozen companies are either marketing or plan to launch tests that measure multiple genes or other markers in order to more accurately detect prostate cancer.

Among these firms are a number of companies who will be familiar to GenomeWeb readers, including GenomeDx Biosciences, Metamark Genetics, Hologic, MDxHealth, Mitomics, Opko Health, Beckman Coulter, and Metabolon.

But the "biggest battle" in the market is likely to be between Myriad Genetics and Genomic Health, the Times says, noting that both firms plan to build on their success in the breast cancer testing market. Myriad's Prolaris test is already available and Genomic Health plans to launch its test later this year.

The Exome is Not Enough

Dan Koboldt at MassGenomics explains why exome sequencing often fails to identify causal variants, even in Mendelian disorders — "the very plausible possibility that a noncoding functional variant is responsible."

Koboldt, the analysis manager in the human genetics group at the Genome Institute at Washington University, says that researchers shouldn't overlook the importance of noncoding functional variants, which require a suite of technologies to detect, including RNA-seq, ChiP-seq, DNAse sequencing and footprinting, bisulfite sequencing, and chromosome conformation capture.

"These types of experiments generate a wealth of data about regulatory activity in genomes," he says. "While studying each of these independently is certainly informative, integrative analysis will be required to elucidate how all of these different regulatory mechanisms work together."

While this effort will require "robust statistical models, substantial computing resources, and productive collaboration among research groups, the end result "will be a far more complete understanding of how the genome works," he says.

This Week in Cell

The Netherlands Cancer Institute's Bas van Steensel leads a team tracking nuclear lamina interactions with the genome in individual human cells for a study published in Cell. The researchers came up with a system in which adenine bases became methylated when they come in contact with lamin proteins that line the inner nuclear envelope. With this so-called 'molecular contact memory' method, investigators followed nuclear lamina-genome interactions in human fibrosarcoma cell lines, getting a look at the lamina-associated genome domains making contact with the nuclear lamina at different points of the cell cycle and in relation to histone methylation profiles. "Contact of individual [lamina-associated domains] with the [nuclear lamina] is linked to transcriptional repression and [histone] H3K9 dimethylation in single cells," they found, noting that this process is mediated, in part, by an H3K9 methyltransferase enzyme.

In Cell's annual special review issue, researchers tackle topics pertaining to the organization, dynamics, and function of the nucleus. This look at the genomic DNA-containing organelle includes several reviews focused on the genome — from chromosomal organization and genome stability to epigenetics and transcriptional regulation. In the same issue, a primer article considers the criteria used to define chromothripsis events in cancer genomes and the National Cancer Institute's Tom Misteli muses on the nuclear environment's role in genome function in his essay on the cell biology of genomes.

Researchers based in Japan, the US, and Austria report on findings from an influenza study suggesting that the influenza A virus may be susceptible to a lipid mediator known as protectin D1, or PD1. The group used a bioactive lipid screen in influenza-infected human lung epithelial cells to find PD1, a derivative of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acid. Through this screen and subsequent experiments, the investigators determined that PD1 not only curbs influenza A virus replication, but that it could also improve the survival of mice infected with the flu virus — even those with late-stage flu infections.

Every Stretch

Depending on how patent claims are interpreted, much of the human genome could be covered by them, say the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey's Jeffrey Rosenfeld and Christopher Mason from Cornell University in Genome Medicine.

Rosenfeld and Mason note that some gene patent claims, and rulings regarding those claims, focus on sequences as short as 15 nucleotides in length. Using the Consensus Coding Sequences database, they determined that 15-mer stretches from every gene in the human genome correspond to at least one other gene — they particularly note that 15-mers from the BRCA1 gene match 689 other genes. "These results demonstrated that short patent sequences are extremely non-specific and that a 15-mer patent claim from one gene will always 'cross-match' and patent a portion of another gene as well," Rosenfeld and Mason write.

They matched known genes to full-length genes included in patent filings, finding that about 41 percent of the human genome is under patent claims. When they examined 15-mer lengths of patented genes, the whole of the human genome appeared to be covered. A gene patented for improving bovine traits, they add, also corresponds to a number of human genes.

"If patent claims that use these 15-mer or other short k-mer sizes are enforced, it could potentially create a situation where a piece of every gene in the human genome is patented by a phalanx of competing patents, with potentially harmful consequences for genetic testing laboratories and research groups performing targeted sequencing on any gene, in virtually all species," they argue.

HT: Mike the Mad Biologist