The Blinded Reviewer

Some journals are exploring double-blind review of manuscripts in a bid to increase fairness and diversity.

Full-text access for registered users only. Existing users login here.
New to GenomeWeb? Register here quickly for free access.

I have done some peer reviews

I have done some peer reviews for the journal Pharmacogenomics that utilizes the double blind methodology. I think it is a good idea that keeps the focus on the merits of the paper.

...when it comes to the point

...when it comes to the point of "guessing the author" of a particular paper the correct guessing is the same danger as the wrong "guessing"; both can lead to bias, in favor of or against, again both spoiling the relaiability and fairness of the peer review.